Context photo: The dome and columned facade of the California State Capitol beneath a blue sky.
Civic policy

Does California's AB 2624 Criminalize Exposing Taxpayer Fraud?

A new law dubbed the 'Stop Nick Shirley Act' by critics faces claims that it targets whistleblowers.

The claim

Gavin Newsom and California Democrats passed a law known as the 'Stop Nick Shirley Act' to criminalize the exposure of taxpayer fraud in immigrant service nonprofits and Medicaid schemes.
View original claim · GuntherEagleman
Original wording

🚨 CALIFORNIA JUST MADE IT A CRIME TO EXPOSE THEIR FRAUD Nick Shirley exposes massive taxpayer fraud in immigrant “service” nonprofits and Medicaid schemes… So Gavin Newsom and California Democrats pass the “Stop Nick Shirley Act.” They didn’t fix the fraud. They

The finding

Governor Gavin Newsom signed Assembly Bill 2624, which expands California's Safe at Home address confidentiality program to include immigration nonprofit workers. Republican critics nicknamed the legislation the 'Stop Nick Shirley Act' and claimed it would hinder the exposure of fraud, but the law does not criminalize the exposure of taxpayer fraud; it only penalizes the posting of personal information or images when done with the specific intent to incite imminent great bodily harm or threaten service providers.

Context

Governor Gavin Newsom signed Assembly Bill 2624, which expands California's Safe at Home address confidentiality program to include immigration nonprofit workers.

Evidence

Republican critics nicknamed the legislation the 'Stop Nick Shirley Act' and claimed it would hinder the exposure of fraud.

Analysis

The law's text does not criminalize journalism or the exposure of taxpayer fraud. It specifically penalizes the posting of personal information or images when done with the intent to incite imminent great bodily harm or threaten service providers.

The claim that the law criminalizes the exposure of fraud is false, though the nickname used by critics is accurately associated with the bill.

Sources

  1. Newsom signs bill derided by GOP as 'Stop Nick Shirley Act'
    sfchronicle.com
  2. Gavin Newsom signs ‘Stop Nick Shirley Act’ expanding protections for immigrant service workers
    news.meaww.com
  3. Are California lawmakers trying to criminalize journalists?
    kcra.com
  4. Critics say new 'Stop Nick Shirley Act' will make uncovering ...
    baltimoresun.com
← All fact checks