Civic policy

Are Senate Republicans Trying to Shut Down Social Security?

While some rhetoric has sparked concern, Senate Republicans are proposing legislative fixes rather than program termination.

The claim

Republicans in the Senate are talking about shutting down Social Security.
View original claim · SenAlexPadilla
Original wording

Republicans in the Senate, are talking about shutting down Social Security while supporting tax handouts for billionaires. You know, our earned benefits, that we have paid into. HELL NO, NOT ON MY WATCH.

The finding

Sen. Ron Johnson (R-WI) stated on Fox Business that Social Security is a 'Ponzi scheme' that 'you just shut down,' but he later clarified he used 'imprecise language' and is not proposing to shut down the program. Johnson introduced the Stop Scaring Seniors Act to shore up Social Security funding, and other Senate Republicans have proposed legislation to fix or rescue the program rather than end it.

Context

Sen. Alex Padilla posted on X that "Republicans in the Senate, are talking about shutting down Social Security." His line about tax handouts for billionaires is not assessed here.

Evidence

Roll Call reported that Sen. Ron Johnson, R-Wis., told Fox Business, "It's a Ponzi scheme. You can't fix it. You just shut it down." Later in the same interview he said, "You can fix Social Security and make it solvent." Newsweek reported that Johnson then called his remark "imprecise" and said he is "not proposing shutting down Social Security." Newsweek also reported that he introduced the Stop Scaring Seniors Act to shore up the program's funding. Roll Call described Social Security bills from Republican Sens. Bernie Moreno, Bill Cassidy and John Cornyn, each written with a Democrat. Benzinga also reported Johnson's clarification.

Analysis

The post rests on a real quote. But it turns one senator's remark, which he walked back at a hearing the same day, into the position of Senate Republicans as a group. The same reporting shows Johnson and other Republican senators offering plans to keep the program paying benefits.

Conclusion

Partially true. One Republican senator did talk about shutting Social Security down, then said he is not proposing it. Senate Republicans' bills aim to fix the program, not end it.

Sources

  1. Tempers flare as future of Social Security debated | Roll Call
    rollcall.com
  2. Republican Who Called Social Security ‘Ponzi Scheme’ Poses New Funding Plan - Newsweek
    newsweek.com

Also reported by

These pages were listed in the check but were not read as evidence for this article.

  1. 'I'm Not Proposing Shutting Down Social Security,' Says Ron Johnson, Urging House to Introduce His Stop Scaring Seniors Act
    benzinga.com
  2. Cassidy on Senate Floor: Protecting Social Security Means Protecting America's Fiscal Future | U.S. Senator Bill Cassidy
    cassidy.senate.gov

Methodology note

Selected from the office-based roster: X post by Alex Padilla (U.S. Senator (CA)). ⚠ MISATTRIBUTION FLAG: finding does not support the claim as asserted — consider correcting to likely_false (claim-as-asserted standard).

← All fact checks

Keep exploring

All fact checks